LLC or Inc: Which Type of US Company Should a Non-Resident Choose? Taxes, Investors, Paperwork, the S-Corp Trap and Switching Later
LLC vs C-Corporation for foreign founders: tax compared with real numbers, investors, paperwork, the S-Corp trap, selling the company, and switching later.

Once you have decided to form a US company, the next decision is the type: a Limited Liability Company (LLC) or a corporation (Inc, also called a C-Corporation). Both protect your personal assets, both can be 100% owned by a non-resident, and both are formed without visiting the USA. The difference lies in how they are taxed, how much paperwork they need, how investors see them, and what happens when you take money out or sell.
Most comparisons online are written for Americans, and their conclusions often do not hold for someone living in India, Germany, the UAE, Mexico or the UK. The S-Corporation advice that fills American tax blogs is not even available to you. This guide compares the two from a foreign founder's point of view, with numbers, and ends with recommendations by business type.
Short answer: choose an LLC if you run a service, e-commerce, content or digital business from abroad, want simple administration and are not raising venture capital. A foreign-owned LLC pays no US federal income tax itself; tax arises only on income effectively connected with the USA, and an LLC run entirely from abroad often has none. Choose a C-Corporation if you will raise money from investors, issue stock options, or build a company to sell; it pays 21% federal tax on its profits wherever the work is done, and dividends to you face 30% withholding, often reduced by treaty. Non-residents cannot use an S-Corporation. An LLC costs $249 all-in in Wyoming with UCB; a Delaware corporation costs $358.
How they are taxed
This is the biggest difference.
LLC: pass-through by default
By default an LLC does not pay federal income tax itself.
- A single-member LLC is "disregarded": its income is treated as the owner's. For a foreign owner, US federal tax applies only to income effectively connected with a US trade or business (ECI) and to certain US-source passive income. An LLC run entirely from abroad, with no US office, staff or dependent agents, often has no ECI and therefore no federal income tax. See effectively connected income explained.
- A multi-member LLC is a partnership. The same test applies to each partner's share, and if there is ECI, the LLC must withhold tax on foreign partners' shares. See single-member vs multi-member LLCs.
Even with no tax, there are yearly federal filings: Form 5472 with a pro forma 1120 for a foreign-owned single-member LLC (penalty $25,000 if missed), or Form 1065 for a multi-member LLC. See Form 5472 explained.
C-Corporation: a separate taxpayer
- It pays 21% federal corporate income tax on its worldwide profits, wherever the work is done, plus state tax where it operates. See the 21% corporate tax explained.
- Dividends paid to a foreign shareholder are subject to 30% US withholding, often reduced by a tax treaty. Under the India–US treaty, for example, the rate is generally 25% for an individual shareholder and 15% for a company holding at least 10% of the voting shares.
- Salary or fees paid to you for work you do outside the USA are generally deductible for the corporation and are not US-source income for you, so no US withholding applies. They must be reasonable and documented, and they are taxed in your home country.
So corporate profits can be taxed twice: in the corporation and again when distributed. Many startups never pay dividends, reinvest everything and aim for a sale or investment instead, which is why the corporation still works for them.
Side-by-side comparison
| LLC | C-Corporation (Inc) | |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership | Members; any nationality, any number | Shareholders; any nationality, any number |
| Federal tax on the company | None by default (pass-through) | 21% on profits |
| Tax when money reaches a foreign owner | Depends on ECI; no withholding on distributions as such | 30% withholding on dividends, often reduced by treaty |
| Yearly federal filing | Form 5472 + pro forma 1120 (single-member) or Form 1065 (multi-member) | Form 1120, plus Form 5472 if 25% or more foreign-owned |
| Governance | Operating agreement; few formalities | Bylaws, board, officers, shares, minutes |
| Raising venture capital | Difficult; most funds will not invest | Standard, especially in Delaware |
| Stock options for a team | Complicated | Standard |
| S-Corporation election | Not available to non-residents | Not available to non-residents |
| Banking and payment platforms | Widely accepted | Widely accepted |
| Typical state | Wyoming, New Mexico, Arizona | Delaware (investors) or Wyoming |
| All-in formation with UCB | $249 (Wyoming) | $358 (Delaware) / $299 (Wyoming) |
A numbers example
These are illustrative examples, not client cases.
A founder in India runs a US company that makes $100,000 of profit in a year from clients worldwide. All work is done in India; there is no US office, staff or agent. Ignoring state tax and Indian tax for a moment:
| Single-member LLC | C-Corporation, all profit paid as dividend | C-Corporation, profit reinvested | |
|---|---|---|---|
| US corporate tax | None (no ECI) | $21,000 | $21,000 |
| US withholding on dividend | None | $19,750 (25% treaty rate on $79,000) | None yet |
| Total US tax | $0 | $40,750 | $21,000 |
| Yearly federal filing | Form 5472 + pro forma 1120 | Form 1120 + Form 5472 | Form 1120 + Form 5472 |
In the LLC column, the founder reports the profit in India and pays Indian tax on it. In the dividend column, India taxes the dividend too, generally with credit for US tax under the treaty. The corporation looks expensive for a profitable service business that takes its profits out, and it usually is. The picture changes for a startup that reinvests everything, pays no dividends and aims for investment or a sale, which is the case corporations are designed for.
Two warnings. First, the LLC column depends on there being no ECI: if the founder had a US office or staff, the LLC's profit would be taxed in the USA at graduated rates. Second, your home country may not treat the LLC as transparent. See what changes by country and, for Indian founders, registering a US company from India.
Paperwork and running costs
An LLC needs an operating agreement, a registered agent, the state's annual report (if any) and the yearly federal filing. There are no board meetings and no share certificates. See the complete US LLC guide.
A corporation needs bylaws, a board of directors, officers, issued shares, a share register and records of major decisions. A full Form 1120 is a longer return than an LLC's pro forma filing. Delaware corporations also file an annual franchise tax report by March 1, which can show a five-figure bill if calculated the default way; filed correctly, it is usually a few hundred dollars. See the C-Corporation guide.
| Yearly cost with UCB | LLC | Corporation |
|---|---|---|
| Wyoming: keep it active | $121 | $121 |
| Delaware: keep it active | $523 | $578 |
| Federal tax filing | $300 | Quoted for Form 1120 |
The full yearly picture for LLCs is in what a US LLC costs every year, and our cost calculator compares both entity types by state.
Investors and growth
US venture funds and accelerators almost always invest in Delaware C-Corporations. They want preferred shares, a stock option plan, a standard legal framework and predictable tax treatment, which an LLC does not give them. Investment documents such as SAFEs and convertible notes are written for corporations. If investment is on your roadmap within a year or two, starting as a corporation avoids a conversion later. See raising US investment as a foreign founder.
Selling the company
An exit is taxed differently too:
- Shares in a C-Corporation. A non-resident who sells shares in a US corporation is generally not taxed in the USA on the gain, unless the corporation's value is mainly US real estate. Your home country may tax it.
- An LLC interest. If the LLC has a US trade or business, a foreign owner's gain on selling a partnership interest can be treated as effectively connected and taxed in the USA, and the buyer may have to withhold 10% of the price. A single-member LLC's sale is treated as a sale of its assets.
For a founder building something to sell, this is one more reason the corporation is the standard.
What about an S-Corporation?
American tax advice often says an S-Corporation election saves self-employment tax and is the "smart" choice for profitable LLCs. That advice is written for US citizens and residents. Non-resident aliens cannot be S-Corp shareholders, and neither can foreign companies, partnerships or most LLCs. A single non-resident shareholder disqualifies the company.
Sometimes a provider or an online form leads a foreign owner to file an S-Corp election anyway. The consequences:
- the election is invalid from the start if a shareholder was a non-resident when it was made, and S-Corp status ends from the day a non-resident becomes a shareholder,
- the company is then treated as a C-Corporation, which files Form 1120, pays 21% on its profits, and may have missed filings for every year it believed it was an S-Corp,
- returns filed on the wrong form may need correcting, and penalties can apply.
If this has happened to you, act quickly: confirm what was filed and what the IRS has on record, establish the correct classification for each year, file the correct returns (including Form 5472 where required), request relief where the error was inadvertent, and set the right classification going forward. See missed a US tax filing. If you later become a US tax resident, an S-Corp election may become possible; plan the timing with a US adviser.
| Structure | Available to non-residents? | Company-level federal tax |
|---|---|---|
| S-Corporation | No | None (pass-through) |
| Single-member LLC | Yes | None (disregarded) |
| Multi-member LLC | Yes | None (partnership) |
| LLC taxed as a C-Corporation | Yes | 21% |
| C-Corporation | Yes | 21% |
Can an LLC be taxed like a corporation?
Yes. An LLC can elect to be taxed as a C-Corporation while staying an LLC under state law. A few founders do this to get corporate tax treatment, for example when their home country treats a US LLC as a company and a transparent LLC would create a mismatch, while keeping the LLC's simpler governance. It is not a route to venture capital: investors still want a Delaware corporation with shares. Once the election is made, the LLC generally cannot change its classification again for 60 months. Talk to us before considering it.
What is the same for both
- Limited liability, provided you keep business and personal money separate and maintain the company.
- Foreign ownership: both can be 100% owned by a non-resident, with no US partner, director or officer needed.
- Remote setup: both are formed without visiting, and both get an EIN the same way. See EIN for non-residents.
- Banking and payments: banks, Stripe, PayPal and marketplaces accept both. See US business bank accounts.
- Privacy depends on the state, not the entity type.
- No BOI report: companies formed in the USA are exempt from FinCEN beneficial ownership reporting, under a final rule of August 2026.
Recommendations by business type
| Business | Our usual recommendation |
|---|---|
| Freelancer or consultant with US clients | Single-member LLC (Wyoming or New Mexico). See freelancers and consultants |
| Agency or IT services firm | LLC; corporation if you plan to sell the business or hire US staff |
| Amazon, Shopify or Etsy seller | LLC. See e-commerce sellers |
| YouTube, books and digital products | LLC. See content creators and authors |
| App developer | LLC unless raising money. See app developers |
| SaaS planning to raise venture capital | Delaware C-Corp |
| SaaS bootstrapping | LLC, convert later if needed |
| Trading or investment holding | Depends on the assets. See trading and investing |
| US property | Usually an LLC in the property's state. See US real estate |
| Subsidiary of your existing foreign company | Often a C-Corp; depends on home-country rules. See US subsidiary |
| Co-founders in different countries | Multi-member LLC, or C-Corp if raising money |
Your home country's tax rules can change the answer, so have a short conversation with a local adviser alongside us.
If you already have one and think you need the other
You have an LLC and investors are coming. An LLC can become a corporation by statutory conversion or by transferring its business to a new corporation. Done properly, it is usually tax-neutral, but it involves state filings, possibly a new EIN, and updates with your bank, payment platforms and contracts. Do it at a planned moment, not days before a round closes. Conversion between entity types and states is legal work that we do not carry out ourselves; we form the new corporation where that is the route, and refer you to a specialist for the conversion itself. See raising investment and the Delaware flip.
You have a corporation and it is paying tax you did not expect. First check whether reasonable pay for your own work abroad has been accounted for, and whether the corporation was the right choice at all. A small corporation with no investors can be closed and replaced with an LLC, but the closure is a taxable liquidation for the corporation, so work out the numbers first. Our company closure service costs $249.
You added a partner to your single-member LLC. It becomes a partnership for tax from that date, keeping its EIN. See changing the owners of a US LLC.
More worked examples
These are illustrative examples, not client cases.
The bootstrapped agency. Two partners in Dhaka run a design agency with US clients and no US presence. A multi-member Wyoming LLC files Form 1065 each year; with no ECI, there is no US tax or partner withholding, and each partner reports their share in Bangladesh. A corporation would pay 21% on profits they take out anyway.
The seed-stage SaaS. A founder in Bogotá is in talks with a US accelerator that invests through a SAFE. The accelerator requires a Delaware C-Corporation. Profits are years away, so the 21% rate costs nothing yet, and the share structure and option pool are set up from day one.
The UK consultant. A consultant in Manchester learns from her accountant that UK tax may treat a US LLC as opaque, so profits taxed in her hands could be taxed again when distributed. She chooses a Wyoming corporation ($299) and pays herself a documented fee for work done in the UK.
Common mistakes
- Following American S-Corp advice. It is not available to non-residents and creates years of wrong filings.
- Choosing a corporation for "credibility". US clients deal with LLCs every day.
- Choosing an LLC when a funding round is months away, then converting in a hurry.
- Paying corporate dividends without planning, when reasonable pay for work abroad or reinvestment would cost less tax.
- Assuming an LLC means "no US filing". Form 5472 or Form 1065 is due every year.
- Ignoring the home-country view of a US LLC.
- Paying the default Delaware franchise tax figure instead of recalculating it.
Frequently asked questions
Can I start as an LLC and switch to a corporation later?
Yes. Many founders do, when they raise money. Plan it rather than doing it in a hurry before an investment closes.
Is a corporation more credible with clients?
Not really. What matters to US clients is a proper company with an EIN, a W-9, a US bank account and professional invoices. See W-8BEN, W-9 and 1099s.
Which is cheaper to run each year?
The LLC, in almost every case: fewer formalities and a simpler federal filing.
Can a corporation have only one shareholder?
Yes. One person can be the sole shareholder, director and every officer.
Do I need an ITIN for either?
Not to form the company or get its EIN. You need one only for a federal tax purpose, such as filing a personal US return. See the ITIN guide.
Building a software product? See a US company for SaaS founders abroad.
How UCB helps
We form both LLCs and corporations in every state for non-residents, with the EIN, registered agent and, if you like, a US business bank account and ITIN in the same order. Each year we keep the company active, file Delaware's franchise tax using the most favourable method for corporations, and prepare the federal return: Form 5472 with the pro forma 1120, Form 1065, or Form 1120. Prices for both entity types are on each state page, including Wyoming and Delaware, and you choose LLC or Corporation when you start your order.
Still unsure whether an LLC or an Inc fits? WhatsApp us at +1 406 389 0227 or email enquiries@ucbsolutions.com with a few lines about your business and plans, and we will recommend the right structure and state for your situation.
Let our experts handle it for you
Every business is different. Message us with your country, business type and goals, and we will recommend the right structure, state and package. We do the work; you focus on your business.
This article is general information for non-resident business owners and is not legal or tax advice. Rules and fees change; contact us to confirm what applies to your situation.


